GA Supreme Court Rules No Do-Over For Athens-Clarke 6th District Commission Race


 CORRECTION: This article has been updated to properly reflect Commissioner-Elect Jesse Houle’s pronouns. Grady Newsource regrets this error. 


The Supreme Court of Georgia unanimously rejected a lawsuit that was filed after Athens-Clarke County District 6 Commissioner Jerry NeSmith died. When NeSmith died, Athens-Clarke County voided his votes and declared runner-up Jesse Houle the winner. The group that filed suit argued that Athens-Clarke County should not have voided NeSmith’s votes, and a special election for the full term should have been held. The ruling prevents a special election for a full term.

Justice Charles J. Bethel wrote in an unanimous statement, “Because the applicable Georgia statutes dictate that votes cast…for a candidate who has died before Election Day are void, none of the votes cast for NeSmith had legal effect.”

The lawsuit was dismissed by a North Georgia Superior Court judge this summer.

The Court rejected every point raised by the appellants, saying “The superior court also rejected a number of other arguments raised…including that the Board’s decision violated their rights to vote, to have their votes counted, to equal protection, to freedom of association, and to due process under the U.S. Constitution and the Georgia Constitution.”

Charlotte Sosebee, director of the Athens-Clarke County Board of Elections and Registration, confirmed that the special election for the remainder of NeSmith’s term will be on the ballot on Nov 3. Republican-backed Chad Lowery is challenging Jesse Houle for the remainder of NeSmith’s term. Houle will take office in January and begin a full term as commissioner.

Lowery said in a statement to Grady Newsource that he disagrees with the ruling since Houle did not win the election outright and only by technicality of the law.

“When I win the election on Nov. 3, he [sic] will have lost twice and still take the office. To put it simply, he [sic] is not the people’s choice,” Lowery said.

Houle is relieved the legal battle is over.

“It’s been a lot to juggle all year… this lawsuit dragging on has been a point of anxiety, and a drain on resources,” Houle said.

Grady Newsource reached out to Athens-Clarke County Attorney Judd Drake and David Ellison, the appellants’ attorney, for comment but have not yet heard back.

You can read the full opinion here.

Conner Hendricks is a sophomore intended journalism major at the University of Georgia.



  • Show Comments (0)

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

comment *

  • name *

  • email *

  • website *

You May Also Like

Behind the Assignment Desk

Athens, GA-There are the reporters behind the stories and the anchors behind the desk, ...

Downtown Academy Library Improvements

Local Private School, Downtown Academy, receives about $3,000 in grant money to fund library ...

Murder Trial for Jamie Hood will Cost Local Government

ATHENS- You have heard your commissioners speak frequently about big projects like road construction ...